Domestic Proceedings

RAA Conference on Collecting Bad Debts to Take Place in Moscow
By 8 June, 2016 0 Comments Read More →

RAA Conference on Collecting Bad Debts to Take Place in Moscow

(English text see below) 29 июня 2016 года Арбитражная Ассоциация проводит конференцию РАА «Взыскание долгов в международных спорах».   Место проведения: Москва, Марриотт Новый Арбат, зал Пушкин. Время – 10.00 (регистрация в 9.30) – 18.00. На мероприятии будут обсуждаться следующие темы: Глобальный поиск активов Финансирование арбитража третьей стороной Эксперты в международном арбитраже Обеспечительные меры Подтвержденные спикеры: Медведков […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings, Events
Enforcement of Settlement Agreements Reached in Arbitration and Mediation
By 27 November, 2015 0 Comments Read More →

Enforcement of Settlement Agreements Reached in Arbitration and Mediation

In September 2015 the UNCITRAL Working Group II (Arbitration and Conciliation) continued its work on formulating a legal framework on the enforcement of settlement agreements, including a convention, model provisions or guidance texts. Currently, parties can request arbitral tribunals to record their settlement agreements as consent awards, ie an arbitral award on terms agreed upon by the […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings, Recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards
Consent to Treaty Arbitration Should be Specific, not General
By 2 September, 2015 0 Comments Read More →

Consent to Treaty Arbitration Should be Specific, not General

Recently investors vigorously but unsuccessfully tried to revive an arbitral award against the Kyrgyz Republic in the Russian courts. On 20 July 2015 the Arbitrazh Court of the Moscow Circuit rejected the cassation claim of companies Stans Energy Corp. and Kutisay Mining and upheld the ruling of the Arbitrazh Court of the first instance. The court upheld […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings, Investor-State Arbitration
Yukos Award – Beginning of a New Enforcement Saga
By 10 June, 2015 3 Comments Read More →

Yukos Award – Beginning of a New Enforcement Saga

While the recent agreement between Yukos shareholders and Rosneft settles all litigation disputes between them, it does not solve the existing disputes between Yukos and Russia as a state, in particular the $50 billion arbitration award made by the PCA in The Hague in 2014. As Russia refuses to voluntarily comply with the award, Yukos […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings, Investor-State Arbitration
Приведение в исполнение арбитражных решений на согласованных условиях
By 8 June, 2015 0 Comments Read More →

Приведение в исполнение арбитражных решений на согласованных условиях

Давыденко Д.Л. Международная принудительная исполнимость арбитражных решений на согласованных условиях (International Enforceability of Consent Awards) В статье рассматриваются некоторые особенности применения положений ст. V Конвенции ООН о признании и приведении в исполнение иностранных арбитражных решений 1958 г. («Нью-йоркская конвенция») к арбитражным решениям, вынесенным на согласованных условиях.online pharmacy https://kendrickfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/new/clomid.html no prescription drugstore Проводится анализ того, насколько применимы к […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings, Library
Review of Russian Court Decisions Related to Arbitration: January-May 2015
By 31 May, 2015 0 Comments Read More →

Review of Russian Court Decisions Related to Arbitration: January-May 2015

In January-May 2015 the Russian courts rendered several important decisions dealing with: the arbitrability of public procurement disputes; the effect of pre-existing links between an arbitral institution and a party to arbitration; partial annulment of arbitration awards; and anti-enforcement injunctions. Non-Arbitrability of Public Procurement Disputes Does Not Create Constitutional Issues Application of City Clinical Hospital No. […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
New Draft Law Aims to Bring Arbitration in Russia to Order
By 28 May, 2015 0 Comments Read More →

New Draft Law Aims to Bring Arbitration in Russia to Order

Since 2013 the Russian legislator is reforming arbitration laws of Russia. The reason for the reform was a the lack of consistency in Russian arbitration regulations, existence of so-called “pocket arbitration tribunals” and sham arbitration tribunals. The reform aims to facilitate the stability and transparency of the system. The first draft law on arbitration was introduced by Russian Ministry of […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
The Problem of ‘Pocket Arbitration Courts’ in Russia: Finally Resolved?
By 7 April, 2015 0 Comments Read More →

The Problem of ‘Pocket Arbitration Courts’ in Russia: Finally Resolved?

The recent decision of the Russian Supreme Court in the case of Geotrest LLC v Gazprom Invest Vostok LLC and an earlier decision of the Constitutional Court indicate a significant change in the approach of Russian courts to the so-called “pocket arbitration courts”. These decisions contradict the previous practice and will most likely lead to significant […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings, Recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards
Approach of Russian Courts to International Forum Shopping
By 11 December, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Approach of Russian Courts to International Forum Shopping

Unlike in the United Kingdom or the United States, international forum shopping is rarely at issue in Russian case law or legal doctrine. However, disputes related to forum shopping do arise in Russia: it happens that the same disputes fall within the jurisdiction of national courts of several states, e.g. the national court of the […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
Notice of Arbitration to the Parent Company: Proper or Not?
By 3 September, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Notice of Arbitration to the Parent Company: Proper or Not?

In a recent decision the Supreme Commercial Court of the Russian Federation found that a notice of arbitration proceedings to the parent company’s general counsel was proper in the context of the facts of the case. The decision has also raised discussions about other related issues: first, in which cases could such notice be improper and […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings, Recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards
Arbitrability of Disputes Under Public Procurement Contracts In Ukraine: Recent Court Practice
By 25 August, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Arbitrability of Disputes Under Public Procurement Contracts In Ukraine: Recent Court Practice

Recent judgments of the Ukrainian courts have again attracted attention to the issue of arbitrability, which remains under debate both in theory and in practice in Ukraine. This time court practice deals with disputes arising out of the so-called “commercial contracts related to satisfaction of the state’s needs” (“Public Procurement Contracts”). The judgments discussed in […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Yukos Winning Award: Will Russia Avoid Arbitral Enforcement Again?
By 15 August, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Yukos Winning Award: Will Russia Avoid Arbitral Enforcement Again?

On 28 July 2014 a historic award in Yukos v. The Russian Federation rendered by the arbitral tribunal seated in The Hague finally became publicly available. The tribunal ordered Russia to pay more than 50 billion US$ for its expropriation of Yukos, making this award the biggest one in the history of international arbitration. Considering the circumstances, […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings, Investor-State Arbitration
Unreliable Warranty as a Basis for Invalidity of a Transaction
By 13 August, 2014 Read More →

Unreliable Warranty as a Basis for Invalidity of a Transaction

Foreign and Russian legal practitioners quite often note the absence of legal enforceability of “warranties” as a shortcoming of the Russian legal system. Meanwhile, the situation is changing as, on 10 July 2014, the Ninth Commercial Appellate Court confirmed the judgment of the Moscow Commercial Court acknowledging the legal force of “contractual warranties” and the duty of parties to […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
Russian Courts Approach Framework Agreement’s Arbitration Clause
By 11 August, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Russian Courts Approach Framework Agreement’s Arbitration Clause

Recent Russian commercial court judgments illustrate a new trend in the interpretation of framework supply agreements (“FSA”). The newly developed approach is supposed to become more sensitive to good faith, party willingness and intentions and factual and legal discourse. In Taganrog Automobile Plant v Hyundai Motor Company (case № 15AP-8173/2014) the courts implemented the Russian Supreme Commercial […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
Kiev Arbitration Days 2014: Think Big!
By 25 June, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Kiev Arbitration Days 2014: Think Big!

Kiev Arbitration Days 2014: Think Big! (KAD 2014) will take place on 6-7 November 2014 in Radisson Blu Hotel, Kiev, Ukraine. The conference is conducted under the auspices of the Ukrainian Bar Association. CIS Arbitration Forum is an media partner of the event. The KAD 2014 will bring together world-class dispute resolution practitioners and prominent arbitration experts to discuss problems […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings, Events
Hague Convention Rules Mandatory for Service on Russian Parties
By 2 June, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Hague Convention Rules Mandatory for Service on Russian Parties

Last Friday the Supreme Commercial Court released its full reasons for the decision in Nortel v UNI. The Court ruled that an English judgment may not be enforced in Russia, because the respondents had not participated in the English proceedings nor had they been served in accordance with the Hague Convention. The decision may result in delays in […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
Ukraine’s Supreme Court Confirms the Respondent’s Burden to Prove Lack of Notice
By 27 May, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Ukraine’s Supreme Court Confirms the Respondent’s Burden to Prove Lack of Notice

In a recent decision the Supreme Court of Ukraine confirmed that the respondent may not prevent enforcement of an arbitral award simply by claiming that it had not received notice.online pharmacy https://www.arborvita.com/wp-content/themes/spacious/inc/new/ventolin.html no prescription drugstore The decision also confirms that the respondent may not circumvent the general allocation of burden of proof mandated by the […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Award Enforcement in Russia: Forum Conveniens Rule
By 18 May, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Award Enforcement in Russia: Forum Conveniens Rule

A significant number of foreign assets can be found in the territory of the Russian Federation. As such, the country may become a popular venue for the enforcement of arbitral awards against foreign entities. This post looks at Russian law and practice when it comes to enforcement of arbitral awards against parties that are not incorporated in […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Closer Scrutiny of Arbitral Awards Required If Fraud Is Alleged
By 12 May, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Closer Scrutiny of Arbitral Awards Required If Fraud Is Alleged

Parties’ use of arbitration for improper purposes has been a topic of growing concern for the Russian business community, courts and state authorities. While an extensive overhaul of the Russian arbitration law to address these concerns is underway, courts employ available procedural mechanisms to combat abuse.online pharmacy https://kendrickfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/new/trazodone.html no prescription drugstore This week the Presidium of […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Ambiguous Clause Successfully ‘Cured’
By 4 May, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Ambiguous Clause Successfully ‘Cured’

Russian courts have traditionally been cautious in dealing with ambiguous and too general arbitration clauses. Where parties agree that their disputes “shall be resolved by arbitration” without more the clause is unlikely to be enforced. However, Russia’s participation in the European Convention on International Commercial Arbitration (the “European Convention”) provides a very useful instrument to […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
When It Is Not Too Late to Request Referral to Arbitration?
By 30 April, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

When It Is Not Too Late to Request Referral to Arbitration?

Under article II of the New York Convention if a state court is seized of a matter covered by an arbitration agreement it shall refer the parties to arbitration if one of the parties requests such a referral. In a recent decision the Federal Commercial Court for the North-Western Circuit provided important guidance as to the timing […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Supreme Commercial Court to Address Guerilla Tactics and Notice
By 25 April, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Supreme Commercial Court to Address Guerilla Tactics and Notice

Earlier this year we covered a case, where the Russian courts refused to enforce an award citing lack of proper notice to the respondent. The courts agreed with the respondent that a person purporting to act on respondent’s behalf lacked the power to do so. The story was not over though as this week a […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Enforcement of Russian Judgment in England: JSC VTB Bank v Skurikhin
By 3 April, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Enforcement of Russian Judgment in England: JSC VTB Bank v Skurikhin

A recently-published judgment of the High Court in the case JSC VTB Bank v Skurikhin has confirmed that Russian judgments can be enforced in England and Wales. The English court recovered from the defendant all amounts claimed under the Russian judgments (622 million rubles) with exclusion of penalties because the judge decided “that they are punitive in […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
Disputes Arising Out of Government Contracts Not Arbitrable?
By 25 February, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Disputes Arising Out of Government Contracts Not Arbitrable?

Russia’s highest commercial court has ruled that arbitral tribunals cannot resolve disputes arising out of government contracts. The court quashed the decisions of lower courts granting enforcement of a domestic arbitral award in a dispute between a government agency and a company. The dispute arose out of a government contract by which the company agreed to […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
Russian SCC Says Service under the Hague Convention is a Prerequisite of an Enforceable Foreign Judgment
By 14 February, 2014 0 Comments Read More →

Russian SCC Says Service under the Hague Convention is a Prerequisite of an Enforceable Foreign Judgment

A 28 January 2014 ruling of the Russian Supreme Commercial Court (the “SCC”) will have significant repercussions for international litigation involving Russian parties. According to the SCC a foreign judgment will be enforceable in Russia only if the proceedings were served on the Russian party through official channels provided by the Hague Convention on the […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
Summary Proceedings in Civil Cases: a New Treatise Published in Russia
By 10 December, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Summary Proceedings in Civil Cases: a New Treatise Published in Russia

In late autumn 2013 Infotropic Media publishing house released a treatise “Summary proceedings in civil cases” (in Russian language). The author of this book is Zoya Papulova, a young researcher and a practicing lawyer in Yekaterinburg (Southern Urals). The general editor of the book is meritorious jurist of Russia, doctor of law professor Irina Reshetnikova. The author analyses […]

Posted in: Book review, Domestic Proceedings
Corporate Disputes’ Arbitrability in Russia: A New Opportunity
By 19 November, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Corporate Disputes’ Arbitrability in Russia: A New Opportunity

In a case currently pending before the commercial courts of the North-Western Circuit, the Russian courts will get an opportunity to confirm that disputes arising out of share purchase agreements are arbitrable. Over the past few years several courts have ruled that they are not. With arbitration remaining the preferred means for Russian M&A disputes’ […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Russian SCC to Rule on Tribunal’s Powers to Apply Public Law Rules
By 14 November, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Russian SCC to Rule on Tribunal’s Powers to Apply Public Law Rules

The case deals with the tribunal’s ability to void on the basis of an alleged breach of a public law requirement.  A panel of Supreme Commercial Court judges decided this week to refer the matter to the Presidium. The panel relied on a number of grounds justifying setting aside an award applying such rules. In particular, […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Bankruptcy Cases Not Arbitrable In Kyrgyzstan
By 14 November, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Bankruptcy Cases Not Arbitrable In Kyrgyzstan

A decision of the Supreme Court of Kyrgyzstan of 20 August 2013 confirms that bankruptcy issues are not capable of settlement by arbitration under the laws of Kyrgyzstan. The decision may be seen as a clarification that the relevant restriction applies both to domestic and international arbitration. Facts of the Case In a contract concluded […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Russian Court Recognises Northern Ireland Judgment in the Absence of Special Treaty
By 5 November, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Russian Court Recognises Northern Ireland Judgment in the Absence of Special Treaty

On 8 October 2013 the Supreme Commercial Court recognised a judgment of the High Court of Northern Ireland (the “Judgment”). This is the first time a Russian court has recognised a judgment from this jurisdiction. The Court recognised the Judgment without enforcement because the Judgment does not require monetary recovery. Recognition without enforcement means that the Russian court acknowledged […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
More on Asymmetrical Arbitration Clauses from the Russian Courts
By 31 October, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

More on Asymmetrical Arbitration Clauses from the Russian Courts

In 2012 the Supreme Commercial Courts famously voided a dispute resolution clause, which entitled only one of the parties to choose between arbitration and litigation. Now the Russian courts have to decide whether to enforce a clause, which provides that the buyer should submit all its claims to arbitration, while the supplier should litigate any […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
A Landmark Decision on Validity and Enforcement of Arbitration Clauses in Russia
By 20 October, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

A Landmark Decision on Validity and Enforcement of Arbitration Clauses in Russia

Earlier this week, the Presidium of the Supreme Commercial Court released the full text of its resolution in Bosch v. Avtosped (a case we covered earlier). Unsurprisingly, the court dismissed Bosch’s claims and referred them to arbitration. However, the Supreme Commercial Court used the case to go over some basic rules that the Russian courts […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Russia’s Supreme Commercial Court Questions Impartiality of Party-Affiliated Arbitral Institutions
By 30 September, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Russia’s Supreme Commercial Court Questions Impartiality of Party-Affiliated Arbitral Institutions

The Supreme Commercial Court is set to rule in two cases, which revolve around the fundamental principle of nemo iudex in causa sua. The cases arise out two arbitral awards. First case: the Arbitration Court of Gazprom rendered an award in favour of a Gazprom-affiliated entity. Second case: the tribunal administered by the Center of Dispute […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Supreme Commercial Court to Address Arbitral Tribunals’ Ability to Handle Complex Disputes
By 30 August, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Supreme Commercial Court to Address Arbitral Tribunals’ Ability to Handle Complex Disputes

Later this year the Presidium of the Supreme Commercial Court will hear an appeal in ENEL OGK-5 v CJSC ROS Postakva and Worley Parsons Europe Energy Services Ltd. The issues before the court are the arbitral tribunal’s power to assess evidence and the effect an alleged lack of jurisdiction over part of the dispute has on […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
CAS Confirmed Strict Liability Principle in Match-Fixing
By 26 August, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

CAS Confirmed Strict Liability Principle in Match-Fixing

On 2 August 2013, the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) published a press-release about the decision made in a complex and highly controversial case on match-fixing, involving ten individuals and two football clubs from Ukraine – FC Metalist Kharkiv (“FC Metalist”) and FC Karpaty Lviv (“FC Karpaty”). The Tribunal sanctioned the Sports Director of FC Metalist and six football players for being directly […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Awarding Excessive Amount of Penalty Interest May Contradict Russian Public Policy
By 8 August, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Awarding Excessive Amount of Penalty Interest May Contradict Russian Public Policy

Yesterday the Presidium of the Supreme Commercial Court of the Russian Federation affirmed relevant lower courts’ decisions to set aside a domestic arbitral award. It found that enforcement of an award requiring the respondent to pay penalty interest in the amount clearly exceeding the damages suffered by the claimant violates Russian public policy.  While the […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Russian Supreme Commercial Court on Cross-Border Litigation
By 31 July, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Russian Supreme Commercial Court on Cross-Border Litigation

  Last Friday the Supreme Commercial Court released a long-awaited review of case law in cross-border disputes (disputes involving a foreign party) (for our earlier report on the draft review see here). While such reviews are not de jure binding, they are as a matter of practice followed by the lower courts and provide reliable guidance to litigants. The […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Russian Dallah in the Making
By 14 July, 2013 1 Comments Read More →

Russian Dallah in the Making

In a pending case Russian courts are looking at whether the arbitral tribunal may extend its jurisdiction to the City of Moscow on the basis of an arbitration clause in a contract to which a department of the city government is a party. In March 2013, the tribunal (Professor Sherstobitov (chair) and Professors Komarov and […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Russian SCC to Consider a “Problematic” Arbitration Clause
By 22 May, 2013 3 Comments Read More →

Russian SCC to Consider a “Problematic” Arbitration Clause

On 16 July the Supreme Commercial Court will consider whether an arbitration clause which consists of a reference to the ICC Rules of Arbitration is enforceable. The lower courts ruled that it was not, finding that it was not specific enough, with parties failing to agree on an institution to administer the arbitration. At first […]

Posted in: Commercial Arbitration, Domestic Proceedings
Competition of Russian and Foreign Jurisdictions: a Case Study
By 16 May, 2013 0 Comments Read More →

Competition of Russian and Foreign Jurisdictions: a Case Study

Competition and cooperation between legal systems is the opening theme of the plenary session of the International Legal Forum in Saint Petersburg on 15-18 May 2013. In October 2012 the Presidium of the Russian Supreme Commercial Court (“SCC”) issued a resolution dealing with competition between foreign and Russian jurisdictions which is relevant to this session and of interest to international litigation practitioners. […]

Posted in: Domestic Proceedings
« Previous Page — Next Page »